Apple iPod Patent Dispute: The Microsoft Connection


AppleInsider reports that a Microsoft Research Scientist is disputing Apple's patent ownership of the iPod's input device, based upon a 2002 patent application filed by Redmond.

Apple's patent application lists Jeff Robbin (Apple VP and ex-Cassidy & Greene employee) and Steve Jobs as the interface's primary inventors. The US Patent and Trademark Office finally rejected the patent application last month, AppleInsider says.

A patent application filed 5 months earlier than Apple's in 2002, by John Platt, has led to the rejection of Apple's application. However, AI does not note that Platt was a research scientist for Microsoft, a point reported by The Register.

Platt has had a rejection history as well for his patent applications. The Register also points out that last month's rejection of Apple's patent isn't 'finally final' (it is an NFR or Non-Final Rejection).

To make things even more complicated, Platt filed a patent application several months after the iPod's original release relating to playlists, very like those appearing on the iPod.

Analysis: Probably a storm in a teacup. As The Reg points out, Apple already has plenty of patents covering various design aspects of the iPod, although the scroll wheel is obviously a vital part of the 'Pod's appeal.